Do most ads and commercials for beauty products make girls feel good about themselves, or bad?

Question:
Do most ads and commercials for beauty products make girls feel good about themselves, or bad?
Good
Bad
Both
Total votes: 1
Coming up in The Great Debate
Can girls do something to stop the media obsession with celebrities?
What do you think?
Hey, girls! What questions would you like to see in The Great Debate in upcoming issues? Send your ideas our way, and you might just see them in an issue of Discovery Girls!




















Comments
I think ads for beauty
I think ads for beauty products make girls feel really self-concious about the way they look because they compair themselves to the models that are wearing the make-up. They dont realize that those models aren’t real. Ithink it pressures girls into wearing make-up because they want to feeel better about themselves
beauty products
I think girls our age shouldn’t care about how the models look like. THEY ARE FAKE! girls are beautiful how they are and you don’t need make up to tell it.
i agree with the "fake" idea below
i totally agree with the “fake” idea below, but i do think that they are real still. they are just wearing way too much makeup and that’s why they look fake.
I don’t think that models
I don’t think that models are fake at all!! they are normal people like you and me. when you have a dream you try to make it come true, right? models have just done the same!! they made thier dreams come true! you shouldn’t judge them just because of their looks or job!!
sure that may be true but
sure that may be true but they work thierselves way to hard and that is coming from my heart,most models are anorexic.and when i see some one like that i want to cry because i almost was a model but i didn’t wan’t to do it!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Not True!
Not all models are anorexic and it’s mean to say so because some models out there are real, normal, girls, AND IT’S WRONG TO GROUP ALL MODELS TOGETHER! IT’S BEING PREDJUDICED AND MEAN! I’m not trying to be mean to you personally, but people need to relize that molels aren’t always the “perfect” stereotype girl.
why?
beauty commertials make me feel bad about myself cuz i’m a little bit overweight. maybe if they had “curvey” girls on commertials then all girls would feel good about themselves, skinny and fat(phat :)
Me too.
I’m over weight for my age cause I’m 100 pounds. Please don’t laugh! I try to keep my stomach in most of the time. I assume that the beauty products and women who are skinny make me feel this way. BAD.
ME2!
We can’t all be skinny! Most people in this world r chunky, including me!
MODELS!
Please! Back Off! Not all models are anorexic! I’m gonna be a model! NOT ALL OF THEM ARE!
Ads 'bout Beauty
Ok, ok! Wake-up call here!!! MODELS ARE RETOUCHED BY COMPUTERS! THEREFORE THEY LOOK AND SEEM PERFECT WHICH IS WHY THEY LOOK FAKE!! My opinion about those ads is, they sort of do but not really
You Go Girl!
That is the most true thing i have heared!
i dont think that modles
i TOTTALLY agree with you.iwish everyone would not complain that modles are fake
Sorry!!
Sorry, but the only reason they look fake is not ‘cause “makeup”, it’s ‘cause they use computers to make it look like every single girl in the world needs to look like “that”. (fyi- “UGH!!!” is what I’m saying right now.)
I disagree. Many of the
I disagree. Many of the models features have been changes by the computers. With that technology we could all look like that!
make-up
i totally disagree with make-up. You don’t see yourself in the mirror but a made up model. Girls should’nt wear make-up to feel better about their apperance. YOU ARE BEAUTIFUL AS YOU ARE.
true
I also think from my point of view that models are fake and I don’t think that they feel confedent about thierselves.All of the girls I know are worried that they are not pretty,or that boys don’t like them.I may just be speaking for myself when I say this but I have achne problems and really I don’t care,I dont put make up on my achne because it doesn’t bother me!Yes,ads are just trying to sell thier products to make girls fell pretty on the outside but when they grow up they are gonna look back on thier child hood,and think “why did I fall for those lying,non-working ads?”
I totally belive you
ALL girls are beautiful inside and out. An d it takes someone true in heart to see that. God blessed everyone with their own type of beauty.
Being urself is all thats
Being urself is all thats important! dont try 2 b or look like someone ur not. I dont even wear makeup, although i do wear some if i go 2 a party but not 2 much. Im also very comfortable with myself just the way it is and not afraid 2 say it. So yes i do think that the models make girls self-concious but they should get over how pretty the models r and just shine as themselves loving who they r!
I agree
I agree that girls shouldn’t wear alot of make-up to show their beauty;makeup only ages the skin (that is if you wear too much and wear it constantly). I used to look at the models on the tv and feel like dirt. I used to think”wow. I’m never gonna get any guy to pay attention to me, because I’m so ugly”. But,I forget the models are real normal people like us and everyone has flaws. Every girl has a different type of beauty, and we don’t need any commercial to make us feel bad about ourselves.
beauty
girls should have enough self esteam to not fall for that. the only make up i use gives me a naterual look
Beauty
I definately understand what it’s like to feel like pretty people are better. The truth is their not. Everyone has their good qualities and their bad. I mean, who cares is if you aren’t the most atttractive person in your school. You might be the one who finds the cure for the common cold, or make an important discovery. Looks aren’t as nearly important as the inside! :)
Ads for beauty products
I think some ads for beauty products can make girls feel bad about themselves. Like if you see an ad for makeup you are going to think “Oh may be that would cover up that huge zit iI have!” But you also might think “Oh Iam so ugly that might help, who am I kiding all the makeup in the world would not make me look any better!” In both these examples it is making the girls feel bad. In the fuirst one it is making a girl feel bad about a pimple which is probably just a little red bump and every one gets them it is perfectly normal! In the second it is making the girl feel ugly which she deffinatly is NOT!! Noone is God created us all special,beautiful,and unique eachg in our own special and different ways. You should let nobody make you feel bad because you are different.
I think girl shoudn’t have
I think girl shoudn’t have to be pressured into wearing make-up, it just covers up the real you!
makeup
I think what this anonymous writer said was TOTALLY true. A girl shouldn’t be fourced to do anything she doesn’t want to do, let alone wear makeup. I think every girl has responsibility to make those kinds of choices. If you wear too much makeup you’re covering up your natural beauties!
Girls shouldn’t wear
Girls shouldn’t wear makeup because their beautiful as they are but what’s this that models aren’t real thet’re fake! Models are real people just trying to do what they love and make money, don’t blame the models blame the commercial company!
Girls can wear
some girls feel insecure and they wear make-up thinking that it makes them prettier. some make-ups can be necessary at certain times but sometimes it’s inappropriate.
It depends on the Girl
It really depends on the Girl, some girls feel nice and confident when they see those commercials and ads. While other girls feel rotten and horrible. Eather way, i think we should put the make-up and not appropriate cloths away and be happy for who we are.
-me-
Reply
I think that girls should wear make-up if they feel comfortable or for dance or acting,ect.If they don’t feel comfortable then heck no!
Bad!!!!
I think commercials for beauty products make girls feel bad about themselves, because most of the models in ads are beautiful and skinny, and that makes girls feel like they’ll never look like them. So I think they shouldn’t show ads like that anymore, because it makes girls feel bad.
Dove
Yes, some ads do make girls feel bad. But who really listens to ads anymore anyways?
I love the “Dove” ads because they use normal people not super thin people they use 160lb people instead of 20lb people. I mean who do you really see who looks like they are “Right out of a magazine”?
So what?
It’s ok! It’s not like the models TRY to make us feel bad!!!! That’s how they look and they can’t help it. Mostly people are like,”I should try that new Dove acne cream! It looked so good in the ad.” but that’s THEIR point of view! They may not get the look they wanted,but atleast they tried. I’m NOT offended by it…but sometimes I’m like,”Wow! I wish I was like them.” but then I regrett it all the same.
I want that>>>
I think when girls see ads for makeup and clothes, mostly they say “That’s cool, I want that!” or ” I have to have that!”. We spend a lot of our time worrying about things we want to get and things that we do not have. We need to focuss on the things we have and need. We have food and water and shelter and love, and we should all be THANKFUL for that.
I think...
I think that make-up can be good and a little bad.
Good-Why I think make-up can be good is because if you have chapped lips or bad skin.Make-up can be a good thing.Tip:Just don’t wear to much or you’ll like a clown!
Bad-Why I think make-up can be bad is that,those models are wearing make-up that their stylists made or bought somewhere.When you buy the make-up,you won’t get a good result.It’s either to thick and not shiny or it’s too shiny and it looks like you put on a lot.
Do most ads and commercials for beauty products make girls...
I think both.If you buy it and wear it you feel good if you dont have it it makes you feel bad becase your left out.
guys
I also think that the fact that guys see these commercials, they start to think that the girls in the advertisements are reality and they expect that from average girls. They don’t realize that the image of them is a result from hours of hair, makeup and years of experiences and puberty. and when they don’t see the beautiful girls with amazing bodies, they start complaining which can also lower a girl’s self esteem. It’ll make girls think they’re not good enough because the guys compare them with models. guys need to start realizing the truth!
Hope
I think they make girls feel good about themselves. it gives them hope that without all the make up the models are just like them. So I dissagree with most of the girls i think the ads give girls hope.
NO
I dont think commercials and adds for beauty products make girls feel bad about themselves i am currently a ford model i have done many adds for girls and young teens clothes and beauty .ANy girl who looks at an add of a girl in a commercial (and BYthe way most adds for beauty products have women modeling there products)and thinks ohh i feel so bad about myself needs self confadince and them having low or no self confadince is not the beauty product makers fault.
girls don't need it
girls should only wear makeup if they WANT to. they shouldn’t be pressured by some fake ad. the models aren’t bad and aren’t trying to make girls feel bad. But i do think that the companys with these comercials should put more thought into it. I mean i know it’s up to the girl to beleive it but the comercial doesn’t help.
i don't think so!!!
I don’t think so because Models can’t help looking like that!! It’s their job,to do this stuff—and girls SHOULDN’T feel bad because some beauty ads are FAKES and(maybe the models naturally look that way)maybe they didn’t do it right!! But everyone IS beautiful,so you don’t need some junk on your face to feel that way!
—Isabella
Make-up
Make-up is just supposed to make you look like a prettier version of yourself. But the girls who wear blue and green eyeliner or purple lipstick DON’T look like themselves, and I disagree with that. All in all, wearing make-up is supposed to make you feel more confident, NOT uncomfortable. If wearing make-up makes you feel uncomfortable, then don’t wear it, but if it makes you feel good about yourself, then just a little bit of make-up is fine.
I THINK SO
When you see adds on TV or in magazines… doesn’t it make want to be like that girl? I think so, so you try really hard to be like that and because you can do anything you put your mind to, then when you see the add again you already know you are like that… Im not saying change yourself, Well maybe I am, but when you think about… if you want to change isn’t that you be yourself. Its your life and its your choice!
they make me feel great
ads for beauty products make me feel great! i dont see why everyone else thinks they are o so bad. If a girl is alredy pretty, then they should know that the ads for the beauty products are going to want you to buy the products because you see the girl in the commercial or in the newspaper and she is just beautiful. Then, if you buy the beauty product you will be more beautiful then you already were and people will start to notice you more you look better with that zit covered up and those glossy lips. You will also feel alot more confident! I dont think that I coold live wihout my makeup soooooooooo. Tahts my story!
re:they make me feel great
wow. First of all,that’s exactly why they make the products- becauseyou see the pretty girland youwant to be pretty like her, but then you’ll buy the product and you’ll be upset becauseit didn’t work as well as you thought it would-as well as the girl in the ad said it would. you know why? because she didn’tjust use that one product. that’s not what made her look gorgeous. It was theoverdone makeup and computerairbrushing that made her look like that.Second of all, you souldnt be noticed more because you have that zit covered up or those glossy lips.you should b noticed because of your bubbly and outgoing personality. are you telling me you pick your friends over how glossy their lips are? I think not. and that is my story.
good
it makes them feel good and confedint! Thats just my opinion
Your Own beauty
Makeup can make girls feel like they have to look like the models on the commercels for that makeup or they want to look like them. Mascara is ok to put on but all of the blush, eyeliner, lipstick, eyeshadow, lipliner, and mascara together make them not look like them self. when we get older and have a job then its a time to put on makeup but for right now be yourself. Most likey the girls on that commercel have been doing movies and commercels for a long time. Just show the really u.
=^..^= speaks again
i say that it shouldnt matter about those ads cause they are always modifyed by computer (photoshop). they are made more beautiful, they removed all traces of blemishes on their skin, enhanced color, and a bunch of other i dont see why girls can think that these people are really so perfect. i dont see why girls cant just be happy with themselves, and not try to look like something they are not. how is anyone going to be able to look inside you and see that beautiful girl if you are covered in makeup? i think that you should just try being satisfied with the way you look. if someone critizeises you for how you look just tell them that they should not say such mean stuff and that they wont be able to succeed in life if they insult people like that all the time or even some of the time.
=^..^=, ALWAYS GLAD TO HELP AND MAKE A DIFFERENCE
Bad
I think most commercials and adds make girls feel bad about themselves. They see the perfect, big-chested, gorgeous, un-blemished girls and feel insecure. They wish they were someone they’re not! Often the girls aren’t even ‘real’- they’re touched up. No one really looks like that and it’s a lie to make girls believe it. It’s what’s on the inside that really matters. That’s what girls should be focusing on!!
they dont make you feel good or bad!
beauty adds aren’t supposed to make you feel good OR bad! they are supposed to make you think if you use their product it will make you look like the models in the add.
not really,
see they may not be supposed to make you fell good or bad but they still do.
=^..^=
They should use an alternative
The models in those beauty ads aren’t the average girl.they’re skinny,perfect and it looks like they were modified using an computer.Makers of Ads should consider using average girls for their ads,they would make girls feel less insecure and make them feel alot better about themselves.
Bad ad
I think that is bad… becaucse they make girls feel like they have to buy them to be beutiful. Sooooo not right.
Miranda
pressured
I think ads and commercials pressure girls into wearing makeup. girls at my school have been wearing makeup since the 4th grade! My friends wear makeup and try to talk me into wearing it but i keep saying no. my bffl thinks she has to wear makeup just to visit her grandma in the hospital! so i think commercials pressure girls into wearing makeup
hmmmmmmm
Well I think that beauty prodects are just advertising for better things. I don’t get how it could make you sad… well some people are sad because of the models that are sometimes on. They think that they are much prettier than them. And that’s not true! Everyone is beutiful in there own way. Those people just have to much makeup on and probably don’t even look like that without makeup.
Nobody's Perfect.
In Hannah Montana’s song Nobody’s Perfect Hannah sings about how NO ONE is perfect not even Miley/Hannah. Celebrities acne, braces, bad hair cuts, EVERYTHING. If you see a beautym product add say to yourself “Hey that girl looks nice but I look even better” that’s called a BEAUTYful aditude!
YES!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Do not belive the poster that you see. High tech computers do things, like, make teeth look more white, remove a pimple, all kinds of stuff. So be thankful for how you look!
Casey
P.S. This is true!
It's up to you
I think yes and no. Its up to the girl. THey can choose that it makes them feel bad or they can use their will power to block it out. It really is just advertising. Instead of being upset for what your not, be happy for what you are! And if you are still nervous and upset when you see those commercials, change the channel! Also it doesnt matter how you look, a true friend would see how pretty you are on the inside! Thats all that counts! So next time you see one of those commericals, say to yourself: Im beautiful in my own way
makes us fell bad
they make us feel bad….especially the cllothing ones cuz the models are size 1-6 and not many girlz are that skinny making us feel fat
RE:makes us fell bad
you are 100% right!
good feeling
I just want to let you all know we’re all untitled to our opinion, including me. It may not make others feel good, but the products I buy help me a lot. I actually think they work rather well.
Appearance
I do care about how I look alot and I will admit to wearing make-up. I put on some cover up and lip gloss. I think that beauty ads don’t hurt girls at all when the models they are using are real (and still beautiful) girls. I mean, not all models are anorexic and fake! but some are tho, and those ads can hurt girls. Overall, its up to you how you react; and you have the power not to let an ad or model lower yuor self-eteem or crush your confidence.
—Emy
YES.......&NO
I think yes and no because I use CoverGirl & LipSmacker but just because I like it, not because I want to be like the models they show wearing the product.
TOO SKINNY!!!
I don’t know about other people,but when I see women on TV or beauty commercials who look like they weigh 90 pounds,I don’t feel
jealous at all! I appreciate women and men who are at a healthy size for their height and shape.I like women who look like women,not skinny boys.In my oppinion,I think it looks better when women are shapely and curvy,not bone thin.I CAN be jealous of models like that!
—maddy
away with shame
Yes I think ads and commercials on beauty products make girls who are not as pretty as the perfect girl avertising feel like they need to lose weight or use make up or some product like that and wont feel they have natral beauty.ITS WRONG!!!!!
I am pretty without makeup
When I see an ad for makeup, I really dont care. I dont wear makeup yet, so it make me feel anything different. When I see ads for clothes, that is a bit different, becasue you know, I wear clothes. Some clothes I say, “Oh thats cool!” or sometimes I say “Ew! U-G-L-Y!” Ads for beauty products dont change me or anything like that, because I know that I am pretty inside and out.
You are a pretty person inside and out no matter what beauty products you see.
-Taylor in CO
makeup...who needs it?
I totally agree with you Taylor i dont wear any makeup and i think i look pretty good without it. My friend cant live without makeup and quite honetsly she looks pretty without makeup, sometimes better than with makeup on. You are pretty no matter what anyone tells you.
Makeup only works ON your skin, what matters is what is under your skin, becuase thats pretty without makeup anyway.
No
I think beauty commercials make us feel bad.I mean i feel bad after seeing one. The truth is the women on those commercials are full of Make up. And most of us dont have time in the morning before school. Anyway dont you just want to have a natural glow without makeup. we get so used to make up so that when we’re older we put on a bunch of makeup to make us think that we’re prettier but the truth is we look the best without makeup. so a little cover up is fine but, tons of makeup is’ent.
Not really.......
I don’t think beauty ads make you feel bad about yourself as long as YOU feel good about yourself. Hey, who knows the product they are advertising might even be useful to you! =) You shouldn’t feel bad because a model looks great on a ad, because everyone is beautiful in their own way!
Depends xD
Alot of s i know wear make up because they just want to be cool. But we’re all beautiful and dont need makup anyway. Sure you can wear it, but it’s not to make you look better than you already are.
— Annabelle <3
Totally,100% BAD!
They make us feel bad because they use girl models that are twig skinny,busty,and straight up beautiful.There are millions of beautiful girls out in the world.But they pick the models that the chances of someone being that pretty and a million-to-one.They probably have 5 pounds of make-up on and flat-iron their hair 12 times.Then we go and try to be that pretty,too.When it is simply almost impossible.